Welcome to Tony's Pizza Rahway
Tony's Pizza Rahway, located at 1085 Broadway in Rahway, NJ, is a beloved local pizzeria renowned for its mouthwatering offerings. Customers rave about their signature Grandma Pizza, rich in garlic, fresh basil, and mozzarella, and the indulgent Buffalo Chicken Pizza that consistently brings diners back for more. The establishment boasts a welcoming atmosphere and serves as a go-to for family gatherings and events, with timely delivery and exceptional service being highlighted by patrons. Whether you're stopping by for a casual dinner or ordering in for a crowd, Tony's combines quality ingredients with community spirit, ensuring an unforgettable dining experience.
Tony's Pizza Rahway: Reviews & Ratings
I have cheat meals every Saturday... and for some reason I ALWAYS come back here for them! Best pizza I’ve honestly ever had. The grandma pizza is to die for and the Buffalo chicken pizza is heaven. I’m on a mission to try every single thing in their menu because so far, they have yet to disappoint me! (Even my puppy wanted a piece of this heaven in the photo!)
We ordered 27 pizzas from Tony's yesterday for our 5th grade pool party. The pizza was delivered right on time and was very reasonably priced. It was delicious, everyone loved it! My family also orders from Tony's all the time. It's our favorite local pizza spot!
This is a pizzeria I frequent time to time since it’s a neighborhood pizzeria for me. My go to here is their grandma pizza. I’ve never had a bad grandma pie from here. Great flavor overall. You taste garlic, fresh basil, mozzarella cheese, and a very tasty sauce.
We couldn’t be more grateful for this amazing local pizzeria! Not only is their pizza absolutely delicious and always delivered hot, but their team went above and beyond in supporting our school’s fifth-grade events. The ordering process was smooth and easy, and the staff was kind, helpful, and professional throughout. Delivery was right on time, and the service was truly impeccable. Whether you’re ordering for a family dinner or a large group, I can’t recommend them enough. A huge thank you for being such a generous and reliable part of our community!
Very small tables inside but enough seats for about 20 people. Mostly for takeout and delivery! Staff was very friendly and accommodating, we had a party of 8 people and the food was served to us hot and delicious. Little bit of a wait because it was Labor Day! And they were getting slammed with orders, but handled it so professionally! We had lasagna pizza that was loaded with topping and delicious! Cheese pizza, Eggplant parm hero really good, the bread was amazing! Rice ball parm yummy! Best French fries we ever had piping hot and crunchy on the outside and tender on the inside. A giant meatball Stromboli, chicken parm meal with pasta, salad and bread, chicken fingers, ham and cheese hero and a Philly cheese steak. We loved everything but the Cheesesteak was not cheesy enough and the meat was chopped too much and a bit dry, the bread was amazing though! Good prices, yummy food and great service! Definitely will be back!
We had a 8th grade pool party today and we ordered 33 pies. He delivered them hot, on time and they were delicious. Tony’s Pizza is the best in town!!!
On its website, Tony's touts its customer service as well as its "fresh ingredients." No doubt a refreshing exercise in truth-in-advertising. Your order may take a few extra minutes, but every element is always very high quality. I had the meatball parm hero today (see photo), and the Stromboli is highly recommended as well. I will return for the pizza. Small dining area, but always clean and friendly, and the food is always tops.
An amazing comfort food spot, especially while I'm in palliative care living in the hospital.Found them on "slice" - quick kind personal delivery the Alfredo fettuccine with chicken is so good & the chicken isn't dry!
Location
-
1085 Broadway, Rahway, NJ 07065, United States Hotline: +1 732-388-9667
Welcome to Tony's Pizza Rahway, a beloved local pizzeria nestled at 1085 Broadway, Rahway, NJ. Known for its vibrant flavors and warm community spirit, Tony's has quickly become a go-to destination for pizza lovers and families alike. Whether you’re craving a classic slice or something a bit more adventurous, this pizzeria promises an extraordinary dining experience.
The heart of Tony's lies in its exceptional menu, crafted with passion and a commitment to quality. Customers rave about the grandma pizza, a splendid combination of fresh basil, garlic, and rich tomato sauce. One visitor, Robert Fagan, noted that he has never encountered a bad slice here, and it's clear why. The authentic flavors that emerge from their kitchen are nothing short of spectacular, promising satisfaction with every bite.
Let’s not forget the innovative options like the Buffalo chicken pizza. Abraham Budhram describes it as "heaven," which raises the bar for what pizza can be. This dish, like many others on their diverse menu, showcases Tony's ability to blend tradition with a modern twist, satisfying both nostalgic cravings and contemporary tastes.
For events and gatherings, Tony's proves to be an accommodating choice. Their reputation shines through in reviews like that of Kira Miller, who commended their reliable service during a school event. Her experience echoes through the community—timely delivery, delectable pizza, and an eagerness to lend a hand when needed.
With a cozy seating area perfect for intimate gatherings, Tony's also caters to customers who prefer taking their meals home or having them delivered. Eric Salsburg, one frequent visitor, highlighted the tasty variety from lasagna pizza to hearty heroes. His experience encapsulates the essence of Tony's: comfort food delivered with warmth, exceeding expectations every time.
In essence, Tony's Pizza Rahway is more than just a pizza place; it’s a hub for community fellowship, exceptional flavors, and memorable meals. Whether you're a Rahway local or just passing through, make sure to stop by and experience the joy that comes from a perfect slice of pizza. You might just find your new favorite spot!